Comparison

Intrufend vs Suricata vs Snort

Honest, detailed comparison across performance, protocols, features, and OT/ICS capabilities.

Suricata and Snort are excellent, mature products. This comparison highlights where Intrufend offers different tradeoffs — particularly for OT/ICS networks and high-throughput deployments.

Overview

At a Glance

IntrufendSuricataSnort 3
FocusOT/ICS networksIT networks (some OT)IT networks
ArchitectureMulti-process (crash isolation)Multi-threadedMulti-threaded
LicenseProprietary (free + OEM)GPL-2.0GPL-2.0
Maintained byIntrufend ProjectOISFCisco / Talos
Plugin languageRust (memory-safe)C + Rust (new parsers)C++

Performance

Detection Throughput

Same hardware, same rules, same traffic. Intel Xeon E3-1225 v5, 4 cores, 8GB RAM.

MetricIntrufendSuricata 7.0.3
Detection PPS (single core)130K+~71K
Live capture throughput1.6 Gbps~215 Mbps
Startup time3.1s25.7s
Live capture drops0%52.3%
Memory (RSS)~734 MB~725 MB

Multi-Core Scaling (DPDK)

Projected throughput with DPDK capture. Intrufend scales linearly due to zero-contention architecture.

CoresIntrufendSuricataAdvantage
1~2 Mpps~2 MppsParity
4~8 Mpps~6 Mpps+33%
8~15 Mpps~10 Mpps+50%
16~28 Mpps~14 Mpps+100%
32~50 Mpps~18 Mpps+178%
64~90 Mpps~20 Mpps+350%

Intrufend projections based on per-packet overhead analysis. Suricata numbers from public benchmarks.

Protocol support

OT/ICS Protocols

ProtocolIntrufendSuricataSnort 3
Modbus TCPFull deep inspectionBasic keywordsVia plugin
Modbus RTU (serial)Native + serial captureNoNo
DNP3Full stack with CRCBasic parserVia plugin
IEC 60870-5-104Full deep inspectionNoNo
S7Comm / S7Comm-PlusFull deep inspectionNoNo
EtherNet/IP + CIPFull deep inspectionBasic keywordsVia plugin
OPC UAFull deep inspectionNoNo
IEC 61850 (MMS/GOOSE/SV)Full deep inspectionNoNo
PROFINETFull deep inspectionNoNo
BACnetFull deep inspectionNoNo
CODESYS V3Full deep inspectionNoNo
TriStation (Triconex)Full deep inspectionNoNo
UMAS (Schneider)Full deep inspectionNoNo
DeltaV (Emerson)Full deep inspectionNoNo
GE SRTP/EGDFull deep inspectionNoNo
FINS (OMRON)Full deep inspectionNoNo
HART-IPFull deep inspectionNoNo
ABB, Honeywell, Yokogawa, SELFull deep inspectionNoNo
OT Protocol Count36+~3~2

IT Protocols

ProtocolIntrufendSuricataSnort 3
HTTP/1.xYesYesYes
TLS (JA3/JA3S)YesYes (+ JA4)Basic
SSH (HASSH)YesYesBasic
DNSYesYesYes
SMB/SMB2YesYesYes
RDPYesPartialNo
QUICYesYesBasic
MQTTYesYesNo
CoAP / AMQP / SIPYesNoNo
IMAP / POP3 / MS-SQLYesBasic/NoNo
Total Protocols68~25~15

Features

Detection & Analysis

FeatureIntrufendSuricataSnort 3
Rule formatSuricata-compatible + YAMLSuricata rulesSnort rules
Community rules (ET Open)Load directly (49K+ rules)Load directlyConversion needed
OT-specific rule keywords40+ fields across all protocolsLimited (modbus, dnp3)Very limited
Semantic event matchingYes (write_command, mode_change, program_upload, ...)NoNo
Anomaly baseline learningYes (1-30 day configurable)NoNo
Passive asset discoveryYes (from protocol traffic)NoNo
Device role inferenceYes (PLC, RTU, HMI, SCADA, SIS)NoNo
IT/OT boundary detectionYes (cross-zone traffic alerting)NoNo
File extraction11 protocols (HTTP, FTP, SMB, S7Comm, CIP, OPC UA, ...)HTTP, FTP, SMB, SMTP, NFSHTTP, FTP
TLS inspectionJA3/JA3S + policy enforcementJA3/JA3S/JA4Basic
Flow bypassBuilt-in (with periodic re-inspection)eBPF/XDP (external, Linux-only)No

OT/ICS-Specific Capabilities

CapabilityIntrufendSuricataSnort 3
Designed for OTYes (primary focus)IT-first, OT bolted onIT-only
PLC program transfer detectionYes (S7Comm, CODESYS, TriStation, CIP, DNP3)NoNo
PLC mode change detectionYes (Run/Program/Stop)NoNo
Write command awarenessSemantic detection (not just byte matching)Keyword matching onlyNo
Safety system (SIS) awarenessYes (Triconex, SIL-rated devices tracked)NoNo
Asset databaseBuilt-in (persisted, pre-seeded from YAML)NoNo
Maintenance window suppressionYes (scheduled silence windows)NoNo
Serial / RS-485 captureNative (Modbus RTU framing)NoNo
Vendor-specific protocols15+ (ABB, Emerson, GE, Honeywell, Schneider, Siemens, Yokogawa)00
Compliance (NERC CIP, IEC 62443)Asset tracking + baseline auditingManualNo

Architecture & Deployment

FeatureIntrufendSuricataSnort 3
Processing modelMulti-process (crash isolation)Multi-threaded (shared fate)Multi-threaded (shared fate)
Crash recoveryAuto-respawn crashed workersFull engine restart requiredFull engine restart required
Core scalingLinear (no contention)Diminishing returns >16 coresDiminishing returns >8 cores
DPDK captureAuto-detected, per-worker queuesYes (since 7.0)Yes (via DAQ)
Zero-downtime upgradeYes (automatic rollback on failure)No (restart required)No
Config hot-reloadSIGHUP (rules, protocols, output, anomaly)SIGHUP (rules only)No
Engine binary size200 KB + loadable plugins~20 MB (monolithic)~30 MB (monolithic)
Per-protocol enable/disableYes (config-driven)NoNo
Plugin crash isolationWorker respawn, others unaffectedEngine crashEngine crash
PlatformFreeBSD + LinuxLinux (primary), FreeBSDLinux

Output & Integration

FeatureIntrufendSuricataSnort 3
JSON log (eve.json)YesYesYes
Kafka (native)Yes (per-topic routing, file streaming)Via pluginVia plugin
Syslog (CEF/LEEF)Yes (UDP/TCP/TLS, multi-server)YesYes
PCAP dumpYes (alerting packets with context)YesYes
REST management APIYes (34 endpoints)Unix socket (limited)No
Management CLIintrufend-ctl (status, reload, upgrade, rollback)suricatasc (limited)No
Self-testBuilt-in (--self-test)NoNo

Recommendation

When to Choose What

OT/ICS network monitoring

Intrufend

40+ OT protocols, asset tracking, anomaly detection, vendor-specific support

IT/OT convergence

Intrufend

Both IT and OT protocols with boundary violation detection

High-speed (40+ Gbps)

Intrufend with DPDK

Linear core scaling, zero-contention architecture

Vendor-specific OT protocols

Intrufend

Only option for S7Comm, TriStation, DeltaV, UMAS, CODESYS, etc.

Compliance (NERC CIP, IEC 62443)

Intrufend

Asset tracking, baseline auditing, maintenance windows

Edge / minimal hardware

Intrufend

200KB engine, efficient memory usage, auto-scaling workers

IT enterprise network

Suricata

Mature, large community, HTTP/2, wide ecosystem

Cisco shop

Snort 3

Cisco integration, Talos rules, commercial support

Try it yourself

Download the Community Edition and run your own benchmarks.