Comparison
Intrufend vs Suricata vs Snort
Honest, detailed comparison across performance, protocols, features, and OT/ICS capabilities.
Overview
At a Glance
| Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus | OT/ICS networks | IT networks (some OT) | IT networks |
| Architecture | Multi-process (crash isolation) | Multi-threaded | Multi-threaded |
| License | Proprietary (free + OEM) | GPL-2.0 | GPL-2.0 |
| Maintained by | Intrufend Project | OISF | Cisco / Talos |
| Plugin language | Rust (memory-safe) | C + Rust (new parsers) | C++ |
Performance
Detection Throughput
Same hardware, same rules, same traffic. Intel Xeon E3-1225 v5, 4 cores, 8GB RAM.
| Metric | Intrufend | Suricata 7.0.3 |
|---|---|---|
| Detection PPS (single core) | 130K+ | ~71K |
| Live capture throughput | 1.6 Gbps | ~215 Mbps |
| Startup time | 3.1s | 25.7s |
| Live capture drops | 0% | 52.3% |
| Memory (RSS) | ~734 MB | ~725 MB |
Multi-Core Scaling (DPDK)
Projected throughput with DPDK capture. Intrufend scales linearly due to zero-contention architecture.
| Cores | Intrufend | Suricata | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ~2 Mpps | ~2 Mpps | Parity |
| 4 | ~8 Mpps | ~6 Mpps | +33% |
| 8 | ~15 Mpps | ~10 Mpps | +50% |
| 16 | ~28 Mpps | ~14 Mpps | +100% |
| 32 | ~50 Mpps | ~18 Mpps | +178% |
| 64 | ~90 Mpps | ~20 Mpps | +350% |
Intrufend projections based on per-packet overhead analysis. Suricata numbers from public benchmarks.
Protocol support
OT/ICS Protocols
| Protocol | Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modbus TCP | Full deep inspection | Basic keywords | Via plugin |
| Modbus RTU (serial) | Native + serial capture | No | No |
| DNP3 | Full stack with CRC | Basic parser | Via plugin |
| IEC 60870-5-104 | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| S7Comm / S7Comm-Plus | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| EtherNet/IP + CIP | Full deep inspection | Basic keywords | Via plugin |
| OPC UA | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| IEC 61850 (MMS/GOOSE/SV) | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| PROFINET | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| BACnet | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| CODESYS V3 | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| TriStation (Triconex) | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| UMAS (Schneider) | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| DeltaV (Emerson) | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| GE SRTP/EGD | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| FINS (OMRON) | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| HART-IP | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| ABB, Honeywell, Yokogawa, SEL | Full deep inspection | No | No |
| OT Protocol Count | 36+ | ~3 | ~2 |
IT Protocols
| Protocol | Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| HTTP/1.x | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| TLS (JA3/JA3S) | Yes | Yes (+ JA4) | Basic |
| SSH (HASSH) | Yes | Yes | Basic |
| DNS | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| SMB/SMB2 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| RDP | Yes | Partial | No |
| QUIC | Yes | Yes | Basic |
| MQTT | Yes | Yes | No |
| CoAP / AMQP / SIP | Yes | No | No |
| IMAP / POP3 / MS-SQL | Yes | Basic/No | No |
| Total Protocols | 68 | ~25 | ~15 |
Features
Detection & Analysis
| Feature | Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rule format | Suricata-compatible + YAML | Suricata rules | Snort rules |
| Community rules (ET Open) | Load directly (49K+ rules) | Load directly | Conversion needed |
| OT-specific rule keywords | 40+ fields across all protocols | Limited (modbus, dnp3) | Very limited |
| Semantic event matching | Yes (write_command, mode_change, program_upload, ...) | No | No |
| Anomaly baseline learning | Yes (1-30 day configurable) | No | No |
| Passive asset discovery | Yes (from protocol traffic) | No | No |
| Device role inference | Yes (PLC, RTU, HMI, SCADA, SIS) | No | No |
| IT/OT boundary detection | Yes (cross-zone traffic alerting) | No | No |
| File extraction | 11 protocols (HTTP, FTP, SMB, S7Comm, CIP, OPC UA, ...) | HTTP, FTP, SMB, SMTP, NFS | HTTP, FTP |
| TLS inspection | JA3/JA3S + policy enforcement | JA3/JA3S/JA4 | Basic |
| Flow bypass | Built-in (with periodic re-inspection) | eBPF/XDP (external, Linux-only) | No |
OT/ICS-Specific Capabilities
| Capability | Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Designed for OT | Yes (primary focus) | IT-first, OT bolted on | IT-only |
| PLC program transfer detection | Yes (S7Comm, CODESYS, TriStation, CIP, DNP3) | No | No |
| PLC mode change detection | Yes (Run/Program/Stop) | No | No |
| Write command awareness | Semantic detection (not just byte matching) | Keyword matching only | No |
| Safety system (SIS) awareness | Yes (Triconex, SIL-rated devices tracked) | No | No |
| Asset database | Built-in (persisted, pre-seeded from YAML) | No | No |
| Maintenance window suppression | Yes (scheduled silence windows) | No | No |
| Serial / RS-485 capture | Native (Modbus RTU framing) | No | No |
| Vendor-specific protocols | 15+ (ABB, Emerson, GE, Honeywell, Schneider, Siemens, Yokogawa) | 0 | 0 |
| Compliance (NERC CIP, IEC 62443) | Asset tracking + baseline auditing | Manual | No |
Architecture & Deployment
| Feature | Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Processing model | Multi-process (crash isolation) | Multi-threaded (shared fate) | Multi-threaded (shared fate) |
| Crash recovery | Auto-respawn crashed workers | Full engine restart required | Full engine restart required |
| Core scaling | Linear (no contention) | Diminishing returns >16 cores | Diminishing returns >8 cores |
| DPDK capture | Auto-detected, per-worker queues | Yes (since 7.0) | Yes (via DAQ) |
| Zero-downtime upgrade | Yes (automatic rollback on failure) | No (restart required) | No |
| Config hot-reload | SIGHUP (rules, protocols, output, anomaly) | SIGHUP (rules only) | No |
| Engine binary size | 200 KB + loadable plugins | ~20 MB (monolithic) | ~30 MB (monolithic) |
| Per-protocol enable/disable | Yes (config-driven) | No | No |
| Plugin crash isolation | Worker respawn, others unaffected | Engine crash | Engine crash |
| Platform | FreeBSD + Linux | Linux (primary), FreeBSD | Linux |
Output & Integration
| Feature | Intrufend | Suricata | Snort 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| JSON log (eve.json) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Kafka (native) | Yes (per-topic routing, file streaming) | Via plugin | Via plugin |
| Syslog (CEF/LEEF) | Yes (UDP/TCP/TLS, multi-server) | Yes | Yes |
| PCAP dump | Yes (alerting packets with context) | Yes | Yes |
| REST management API | Yes (34 endpoints) | Unix socket (limited) | No |
| Management CLI | intrufend-ctl (status, reload, upgrade, rollback) | suricatasc (limited) | No |
| Self-test | Built-in (--self-test) | No | No |
Recommendation
When to Choose What
OT/ICS network monitoring
Intrufend
40+ OT protocols, asset tracking, anomaly detection, vendor-specific support
IT/OT convergence
Intrufend
Both IT and OT protocols with boundary violation detection
High-speed (40+ Gbps)
Intrufend with DPDK
Linear core scaling, zero-contention architecture
Vendor-specific OT protocols
Intrufend
Only option for S7Comm, TriStation, DeltaV, UMAS, CODESYS, etc.
Compliance (NERC CIP, IEC 62443)
Intrufend
Asset tracking, baseline auditing, maintenance windows
Edge / minimal hardware
Intrufend
200KB engine, efficient memory usage, auto-scaling workers
IT enterprise network
Suricata
Mature, large community, HTTP/2, wide ecosystem
Cisco shop
Snort 3
Cisco integration, Talos rules, commercial support
Try it yourself
Download the Community Edition and run your own benchmarks.